Episode 91
October 5, 2026

I Could See These Guys Forming A Prog Rock Band

Hosted by Jared Pechaček, Ned Raggett, and Oriana Schwindt

Jared, Oriana and Ned talk about Ned’s choice of topic: Tolkien’s experiences in World War I. It’s the core of one of Tolkien’s most famous quotes and one of his saddest: “By 1918 all but one of my close friends were dead.” Only 22 years old when the cascading series of events of the summer of 1914 led to what was first called the Great War and in retrospect World War I, Tolkien seemingly had an advantage with some prior officer training and the ability to stay out of the war to finish his studies, but starting in 1915 he joined all of his friends from pre-university days in serving in the British armed forces for the duration of the conflict. Due to a case of trench fever after his time in the horrific 1916 engagement called the Battle of the Somme, much of his later time during the duration was spent on home duty with his wife and first son, but by that time, many of those friends were already gone. While he specifically resisted too much biographical interpretation of his work, there’s simply no question that his experience at least shaped part of Tolkien’s life from that period forward. What can be said of the early work that Garth introduces as Middle-earth coalesces, and is it a case where his friends’ love for it was maybe not too wise but too well? How does that passionate friendship itself play out in their interactions and letters and more, and how much of it seems to be a hangover from their school days and what they felt they could actually say? Is there something about Tolkien’s small-a anarchism that grows out of his experience as an officer in the war, among other things? And exactly how hard was it to track officer luggage back then?

Show Notes.

Jared’s doodle. A dead land indeed.

Want to read more about Jared’s Worldcon time? Head to his Patreon!

Oriana’s forthcoming film once again!

Ian McKellen Gandalfs up once more.

If you want to read more about The Rings of Power, well, there’s this. If you must.

D. J. Taylor’s The King Under the Mountain, if you want to check it out.

Thomas Pynchon has indeed appeared on the Simpsons.

That Eagle and Child Easter egg. And Emma Mackey’s amazing costume.

That famed Tolkien quote about his friends and 1918. (And why that preface exists to start with.)

World War I. Between that and the flu epidemic hot on its heels, no wonder people wanted to party in the 1920s.

The casualty statistics from the war sadly say it all.

John Garth’s Tolkien and the Great War – worth a read.

The other members of the core friendship quartet: Christopher Wiseman, Robert Gilson and Geoffrey Smith. (Wells for boys!)

The Battle of the Somme looms large in the UK perspective on the war.

Gas gangrene – you don’t want to have it.

More on the OTC, or Officer Training Corps.

A little more on the USS Abraham Lincoln’s travails this past summer…

Tolkien, the biopic. A mixed effort but the wartime scenes were good.

So if you’re wondering about the mustaches…

Our Adventures of Tom Bombadil episode is as close to a Tolkien poetry episode as we have.

Radiohead did indeed start off as school pals. But the ultimate ‘public school kids form a prog band’ story is that of Genesis.

Luke Shelton did indeed write a piece on how the ‘mythology for England’ line is overblown in discussion.

“Lions led by donkeys.”

The still famed major World War I writers from the UK: Rupert Brooke, Wilfred Owen, Siegfried Sassoon, Vera Brittain. 

Hilary Tolkien. It’s entirely possible he just was very low-key in general. (There is this posthumous publication from a few years back, though…)

Our episodes on Turin and the Fall of Gondolin.

Support By-The-Bywater (and our network) on Patreon, and you can hang out with us in a friendly Discord.